Peanut butter is not only very familiar to most people but is often a food product that’s considered to be the quintessential comfort food. That’s probably because most people commonly associate it with their childhoods. I know that whenever someone mentions peanut butter to me, it’s hard not to think of the pb&j sandwiches my mother would serve me while I watched Saturday morning cartoons.

The popularity of this food product is also the reason why there are now hundreds of different brands available to the consumer. While this means it’s more available than it has ever been before, it also means that it can be difficult separating the great brands from the merely average brands. And that’s why we’ve selected ten of the best peanut butter products currently available in the following list.

Best Peanut Butters – Reviews

10Teddie All-Natural Smooth

This American-made peanut body is manufactured by a company that’s been family owned and operated since 1925. Why is this little fact important? Because it shows that this company has been personally invested in making the best product possible for decades now. You’ll be able to taste the quality once you’ve placed just one spoonful of it in your mouth. This peanut spread is made without any sugars or preservatives and is not only gluten-free but is also Vegan-friendly. It’s also a non-GMO product, so you can feel confident in feeding it to your family. All of which has made this butter one of the best selling peanut butter spreads in the northeast U.S.

9Hoosier Hill Farm Powder

If you haven’t tried peanut butter in a powdered form, then you may want to check out this product. That’s because it’s not only suitable for adding peanut butter flavor to your favorite baked goods but can also be turned into an amazing sandwich spread by just mixing a little bit of water into it. This product doesn’t contain any artificial colors, flavors or sweeteners and is both whey protein-free as well as soy protein-free. It’s a high fiber, high protein product that contains 25 different essential vitamins and about 100 milligrams of Omega 3 fatty acids in each serving. Which makes this food a very healthy choice for any family.

8Simply Jif Creamy

Jiffy Peanut Butter has been manufactured since 1958, so it’s not only a recognizable brand but is also a trusted brand. And now they’ve taken their original formula and have made it even better. They did this by making this simple formula that consists of just peanuts with a small number of essential oils, salt, sugar, and molasses. This means that it contains no preservatives and is not only easy to spread but tastes great, too. It’s also packed with protein, having about 7-grams per serving and can be used for making sandwiches or for baking. Jiffy Simply Peanut Butter is also made in such a way that it doesn’t need to be stirred, unlike some other natural peanut butter products.

7Peter Pan Creamy

There are probably few people who have never heard of Peter Pan Peanut Butter. That’s because this product has been manufactured by years and has become a trusted brand in many households all over the world. That’s because this peanut spread not only goes on sandwiches extremely smoothly but also has a great peanut tastes. This product is also made without any high fructose corn syrup and is simply made with peanuts, vegetable oils, and salt. And since it comes in a hefty 40-ounce jar, this product is sure to provide just about any family with all of the pb&j sandwiches they want.

6Home Plate Variety Pack

Home Plate Peanut Butter is a brand that makes peanut spreads that not only are more wholesome than some of the other products currently available but also tastes great and doesn’t have a gritty or oily texture. It’s a company founded by ex-baseball players who wanted to capture the nostalgia of what they believed peanut butter used to taste like. In doing so, these players have created a product that contains no GMO ingredients, is gluten-free, has no hydrogenated oils and is certified kosher. This 6-jar variety pack contains a number of exciting peanut butter products including crunchy, creamy, and honey.

5PB Fit All-Natural Powder

Regardless of whether you need a peanut butter powder to use as a protein supplement for your workout smoothie, or need it for your baking needs, this powder is sure to meet your needs and expectations. That’s because this high-quality product is only made with three very simple ingredients: peanuts, salt and coconut palm sugar and nothing else. This makes it an all-natural and gluten-free product that provides a great boost of protein in a person’s diet, doesn’t contain a whole lot of fats and is extremely tasty, too. It’s an extremely good product that’s sure to be a protein powder many people really enjoy.

4Bell Plantation PB2 Powder

With 85% fewer calories than conventional peanut butter products, this easy to use powder can be a healthy part of just about anyone’s diet. It’s only made with three simple ingredients, and these three ingredients are just peanuts, salt, and sugar. Which basically means that this high-quality product is missing all of the poor quality ingredients that are so often found in commercial peanut spread products. In order to this product, all the consumer has to do is mix it with a little bit of water and it’s ready to be used. It can be used for sandwiches, for baked goods or for making healthy protein shakes.

3Jif Creamy Twin Pack

Although this product isn’t as natural as Simply Jif and does contain less than 2% of mono and diglycerides, it is still a tasty spread that just about anybody who loves peanut butter will enjoy. It’s also a spread that goes on bread smoothly and provides about 7-grams of protein per serving. This peanut butter doesn’t develop oil on top of it like some other spreads, so you never have to stir it to mix it all together. This product is considered to be a kosher peanut product and also doesn’t contain any artificial preservatives. It’s a great product for making pb&j sandwiches, for baking or for making dog treats.

2Jif Extra Crunchy

Jif had been making original style peanut butter for over 16-years when they decided to release Jif Extra Crunchy in 1974, and it was almost an instant hit. Which shouldn’t be surprising, because who could resist the taste of this great product? It was great for not only making peanut butter and jelly sandwiches but was quickly adopted for other uses as well, including baking and making dessert toppings. Today, this type of peanut spread is one of the more popular ones available. As their advertising often points out, “choosy moms choose Jif” and that’s because it’s some pretty good peanut butter.

1PB2 Bell Plantation Chocolate Peanut Butter Powder

Chocolate and peanut butter is a great food combination, so it should be no surprise that this product is the top product on this list. It has a great tasting flavor that just has to be tried before it’s believed. However, this product has a lot more going for it than just great taste. This powdered peanut butter is also manufactured in a way that removes up to 85% of the fat from the peanuts during the manufacturing process. It’s also made without any preservatives, sweeteners or artificial flavors. This makes this powder a healthy choice for baking, making into a fantastic sandwich spread or for making into healthy smoothies.

Can’t Find What You’re Looking For? Check these suggestions:

How to Buy the Best Peanut Butter

If you’ve ever walked the peanut butter aisle of your local grocery store or have looked through the selection available online, then you’re likely to be quite overwhelmed by the number and different varieties and brands of peanut butter currently available. It really makes it difficult to find the best peanut butter for you and your family.

Trust me, I know. I’ve looked through the selection at my local grocery store and as immediately confounded by what I found there. And I found myself asking questions that you’ll probably find familiar. Should I buy natural, creamy, or chunky peanut butter? What brand should I buy – Jif, Peter Pan, Skippy, Justin’s, PB Fit or some other brand? What’s the difference between regular peanut butter and peanut powders? I couldn’t answer those questions, and I couldn’t find any reliable information on the Internet, so I decided to do my own research and find answers to all of them. Which is exactly what I accomplished with this guide, so sit back and relax. I have the answers you’re looking for when selecting a peanut butter product.

Look at the Label

The first thing that you should do before you purchase any peanut butter is to look at the label. While this has always been the best way to determine which products were the best, it wasn’t always easy to do if your purchase your peanut butter online. Fortunately, when buying these products on the websites of major retailers, you’ll find that they now include pictures of the label that are clear and easy to read. This makes this process of finding the peanut spread with the best ingredients easier than it has ever been before. So always make sure you head right to the label and check out what’s in your peanut butter.

Peanut Butter Spread Vs. Peanut Butter

Unfortunately, even when a person gets the opportunity to look at the ingredient’s list of their favorite product, they still don’t know what they are looking for in most cases. And I know because I was such a person. That’s why I’m going to give you some guidelines to get you started on your search for the best peanut butter.

  • Peanut Butter: At least 90% of its ingredients are peanuts.
  • Peanut Spread: At least 60% but less than 90% of its ingredients are peanuts.

Peanut butter should contain approximately 90% of its composition from peanuts, and the other 10% should only be high-quality ingredients. This means no artificial sweeteners, no artificial flavorings, and no preservatives. In fact, if this ratio of peanuts to other ingredients isn’t met, then the product cannot be labeled peanut butter, instead, it has to be labeled peanut spread.

Ingredients You Should Avoid

There are a number of ingredients that you may or may not want to avoid. While I’m sure there are ingredients on the following list that some people are completely fine using, I’m going to list them anyway because you should at least be aware of the ingredients being put into your favorite products. For example, some people may dislike peanut butter products that use absolutely no sweeteners of any kind, while other people may be fine with some sweeteners such as molasses or honey. The choice is ultimately up to you, but before you know the ingredients you may want to either include or remove from your diet, you have to be aware whether they’re in your favorite products in the first place.

  • Sweetening Products: This can include a variety of simple sugars or sweeteners in various forms include high fructose corn syrup, sugar cane juice, molasses, honey and corn syrup solids. All of these should be avoided in your peanut butter, but if you dislike unsweetened peanut butter products, then at least choose a product that doesn’t contain high fructose corn syrup and uses a more natural sweetener like plain sugar or honey.
  • Reduced Fat Products: While I’m not necessarily saying that you should avoid all low-fat peanut butter products, it’s important that you look closely at their labels. That’s because many manufacturers add extra sugar or fillers to compensate for the loss of fats to make their product taste better.
  • Artificial Products: As I said above, you should avoid preservatives, artificial sweeteners, and artificial coloring or flavoring. They just aren’t good for you and they aren’t needed to make a great tasting peanut butter.
  • Hydrogenated Oils: These oils add unhealthy fats to the butter and should be avoided. Common hydrogenated oils include cottonseed oil and palm oil.

Avoid Peanut Butter/Jelly Spreads

I’m not sure if you’re familiar with peanut spreads which contain both peanut spread and jelly mixed together. While I’ve enjoyed these products in the past, especially when I was a young child and find some of them to be quite tasty, they can also be full of unhealthy ingredients. It appears that it takes a bit of “commercial voodoo” to put peanut spread and jelly together into one product. They often have to use not only palm oil to solidify the whole product but also a number of different preservatives to give it a decent shelf life. So do yourself a favor and buy your peanut butter and jelly separately and then put it together yourself – it’s a lot healthier.

Tips on Making Great Peanut Butter & Jelly Sandwiches

Now that you know how to buy the best peanut butter product, it’s time to put it to work in a great pb&j sandwich. With that in mind, we’ve included some tips that will make your peanut butter and jelly sandwiches taste a whole lot better.

  • Put Peanut Butter on Both Slices of Bread: To keep your jelly from seeping through your bread, spread your peanut butter evenly on both slices of the bread before you add the jelly. If you’re worried about adding too much, then just use half the amount on each slice you would normally place on just one slice of bread and you’ll be fine.
  • Use a High-Quality Jelly or Jam: Don’t settle for bargain basement jellies. Instead, spend the extra money and buy a high-quality product. In the end, you’ll be glad you did.
  • Don’t Add Too Much: Other sandwiches such as Hero Subs, Italian Beef Sandwiches, and Lobster Rolls may benefit from an abundance of toppings, peanut butter, and jelly sandwiches do not. Which is why you should keep it to 2-tablespoons or less of each product for a great tasting sandwich.