There shouldn’t be any doubt in anybody’s mind that drugstore liquid eyeliners are by far the most practical out there, both in regards to their availability and their ease of use. Ideal for creating sharp, refined lines in a cost-effective manner, these eyeliners are enjoying quite the popularity nowadays and for good reasons. While there may be sub-standard drugstore products that barely meet the basic requirements, you shouldn’t have too many issues finding a good one if you do your homework before committing to a purchase.

As long as you bear in mind that not all eyeliners are created equal, you should be able to find one or even a handful that meet your needs. To ensure that, you should take the time and learn as much as you can about what makes a good eyeliner and what characteristics to look for when buying one. To give you a better idea of what’s out there, we put together a list of the ten best drugstore liquid eyeliners the market has to offer at this point in time.

Best Drugstore Liquid Eyeliners – Reviews

10Milani Stay Put Matte Liquid Liner

Delivering intense color for up to 17 hours, the Milani Stay Put Matte Liquid Liner is a high-quality product that will definitely enhance your style. Designed with a sleek felt tip brush, this eyeliner allows you to easily create your own desired look, whether bold or simple with just one single step. Resistant to sweat and humidity, it is formulated with premium grade ingredients that are safe for your eyes. Available in 4 rich and highly pigmented colors, it is great for daily use. That said, remember to always use an oil-based makeup remover for easy removal of the eyeliner without smearing.

9COVERGIRL Super Sizer Intensify Me! Eye Liner

The CoverGirl LashBlast Intensify Me Liquid Liner is a premium grade eyeliner made from high-quality ingredients. Tested and approved by expert ophthalmologists and dermatologists, this product is safe for you and is suitable for those who have extra sensitive eyes. Designed with a paddle tip, you can achieve two stunning looks including a thick deep look or a thin elegant look. Quickly drying, this eyeliner features an intense black liquid that flows easily, leaving you with sleek, precise lines. Easy to remove, it can be wiped off with soap and water.

8Nyx Professional Makeup Liquid Liner

Ideal for the modern cat-eye effect, the Nyx Professional Makeup Liquid Liner comes in a beautiful rich white color that will make your eyes stand out. Unlike others, this white liner can also be utilized under other colored liners to help enhance and make the colors pop. Quick drying and easy to apply, it dries to a matte finish and looks elegant and classy. Resistant to water and smudging, it is formulated with high-quality ingredients that are safe for sensitive eyes.

7Maybelline Curvitude Liner

Featuring a uniquely designed applicator, the Maybelline Curvitude Liner is the first ever angled liquid liner. Crafted with a curved tip, this pen eyeliner comes equipped with an extra fine flexible tip made from sturdy felt. Thanks to its versatile design, it glides across the curves of the eye and behind the lash line, leaving you with a sleek, flawless line. Long-lasting, quick drying, and formulated with high-quality ingredients, this eyeliner is perfect for daily use and suitable for sensitive eyes.

6Long & Luscious Liquid Eyeliner

Uniquely designed with an easy to use pointed felt tip, the Long & Luscious Liquid Eyeliner allows you to create a dramatic or elegant effect, depending on the thickness you desire. Resistant to smudging and water, this eyeliner does not smear, although it comes off easily with some soap and water. Available in two colors, respectively black and chocolate brown, this eyeliner is ideal for daily use, giving you that gorgeous effect you want.

5Blinc – Extreme Longwear Liquid Eyeliner

Crafted to easily contour the shape of your eyes, the Blinc – Extreme Longwear Liquid Eyeliner produces a layer of intense color that is resistant to water and smudge proof. Thanks to its unique formula and premium quality set of ingredients, it is unlike any other conventional liner and does not flake, smudge or run. Highly pigmented, it can be utilized to create a dramatic thick look, luscious cat eye effect or a sleek, elegant look. For easy removal, simply use warm water and a cotton ball and rub gently.

4Nyx Professional Makeup Matte Liquid Eyeliner

Another premium product from Nyx Professional is this exceptional matte liquid liner. Uniquely crafted to allow you to create smooth, precise lines with minimum effort, this liquid liner dries quickly and with a matte finish. Thanks to its special precision brush it allows you to create a flawless cat-eye effect which is now popular. Formulated to give you highly pigmented bold and classic looks, it is highly recommended by experts and seen as one of the best of its kind.

3Revlon ColorStay Skinny Liquid Eyeliner

Delivering sleek, slim precise lines with highly pigmented color, the Revlon ColorStay Skinny Liquid Eyeliner is crafted to accentuate your beauty to the next level. Featuring an ultra-thin 0.1mm felt tip, it is formulated with a unique set of long-lasting ingredients that won’t fade or smear through the day. Tested and approved by experts, this eyeliner is safe for sensitive eyes as well as for those who wear contact lenses on a regular basis. Ideal for the cat-eye effect, elegant thin lines or dark, thick dramatic eyes, this liner is great for daily use.

2Physicians Formula Eye Booster 2-in-1 Lash Boosting Eyeliner

The Physicians Formula Eye Booster 2-in-1 Lash Boosting Eyeliner is a high-end product that features a special Japanese blend of ingredients. Resistant to water and smudging, this eyeliner provides you with hours of intense, rich color that will not smear even if rubbed. Thanks to its ultra-sleek brush applicator, it makes application easy and effortless. Free from parabens and artificial fragrances, it is tested and approved by expert dermatologists and is hypoallergenic. Formulated with high-quality ingredients, it is suitable for those who have sensitive eyes as well as for those who wear contact lenses.

1Stila Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner

The Stila Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner is without a doubt, one of the best eyeliners out there, one that comes highly recommended by salons and users across the globe. Giving you the option of creating a range of defining effects, it enables users to create dramatic, elegant and rich looks, effortlessly. Thanks to its unique formula it glides on smoothly and easily and dries up quickly without smudging or smearing. Featuring a fine tip marker-like applicator, it can be utilized by beginners and experts, leaving you with a precise, flawless application.

Can’t Find What You’re Looking For? Check these suggestions:

What To Look For In An Eyeliner

Given the sheer number of eyeliners available out there, it may be a bit underwhelming to find a decent one that meets all your personal requirements. Still, if you take the time to do your homework, you are bound to find a good one at an affordable price. Chances are that you won’t even have to buy one made by a world-renowned manufacturer, not as long as there are drugstore versions that meet roughly the same standards. Provided that you take the time and consider the exact specifications of each eyeliner that catches your eye, you are bound to eventually find one that suits your needs.

The Right Eyeliner

You need to understand that the wide range of eyeliners out there is only confusing if you’re unaware of the many different types there are. For instance, you have brush applicator liquid eyeliners, cream eyeliners, gel eyeliners, felt-tip applicators, mechanical twist-up eyeliners, pencil eyeliners, and even a few eyeshadow eyeliners that can be used for roughly the same purpose. Now, either one of these eyeliners can be used for common eye lining purposes and using one usually comes down to personal choice. After all, you should only use an eyeliner you feel comfortable using.

Preparation Is Key

Before the actual eyeliner application process begins, you should take the time and prepare your eyelids the proper way. In this respect, you want to first remove any makeup you might already have on from the day before, not just for hygiene purposes but also to aid with the application of new layers of makeup. You can do that by employing a makeup remover of your choosing, one that you can depend on not to leave behind any unwanted traces of grease or oil. Afterward, you want to apply the makeup starting with the primer, followed by eyeshadow, and then the actual eyeliner.

Remember The Dot & Dash

Many of you might already be familiar with the dot & dash method, which is a quite popular method of applying eyeliner. With this technique, you don’t really need an overly steady hand, which means that you are allowed the occasional mistake without any real consequences. All you have to do is draw dots and dashes along the lids to guide you through so that you simply have to follow the dashes and draw a line. Needless to say, this method is a lot easier than trying to draw an uninterrupted line by hand from the first try. Try your best to connect all the dots and not miss any along the way, less you want to do any correction work afterward.

Always Double Check

Once you have applied the eyeliner using whatever method you see fit, remember to check the end result as closely as possible. Try to also ensure that everything looks smooth and properly articulated. This can be done by drawing along the edge of the liner to boost its overall design. If you want, you can also tail your eyeliner for a more sublime look. Bear in mind that this takes a little skill on your part, so perhaps keep it in your repertoire until you have mastered the art of applying eyeliner to some extent.

Application Tips

While some women wrongfully assume that applying eyeliner isn’t exactly hard, not everyone shares the same hand-eye coordination. In fact, some women find it rather difficult to simply draw the line along the natural curvature of the eyes, which is where the many different application techniques come into play. If you are even the least bit concerned or unsure of what you’re doing, try to remember there is no shame in looking for help.

  • Use A Handheld Mirror – By using a rear-view mirror or bathroom mirror, you are bound to miss a few details every once in a while, mostly because of the viewing angle. What you want instead is to always employ a handheld or compact mirror that you can maneuver as you see fit for greater visibility. Such a mirror can also help you with applying another type of makeup farther down the line so consider it an investment into your own future.
  • Draw A Close Line – Try your absolute best to apply the eyeliner as close to your eyelashes as humanly possible. We say this because unwanted gaps between the eyeliner and the lashes make the whole thing look a bit sloppy and why not, even trashy. By ensuring that there aren’t any visible gaps, you also make sure that you will be able to remove the eyeliner easier when it’s time to clean it all up at the end of the day.
  • Never Draw Tails Downward – If you have any experience with applying eyeliner, you should already know that drawing tails downward is frowned upon. This is because it will end up making your eyes look droopy and tired. Unfortunately, many women do this by mistake simply because they lack a steady hand or because they are in a hurry. A good way to avoid doing this is to first place a dot where you want the tail to swing upward and connect it to the rest of the eyeliner.
  • Avoid Thick Lines – Another important thing to remember is to always avoid thick lines. The reasons for this are mostly aesthetic and they revolve around the wrong impression that some women have that thicker lines add a more seductive look to their eyes. The result is usually quite different as such a technique is guaranteed to make the eye seem smaller along with making the lids look heavier. This has the unfortunate effect of making you look tired and even odd to some extent, which is bound to draw the wrong sort of attention.